How to make a nanny share work

Rachel Carrell - Rachel againRachel Carrell of nanny share company Koru Kids gives her tips on how to make a nanny share work for you.

Nanny sharing is an increasingly popular option to keep the cost of childcare under control. Nanny share means that the nanny looks after children from two families at the same time. Done right, it’s a win-win solution: the nanny gets paid more per hour while each parent pays less, and the children get a friend to play with.

Given the recent news that British parents pay up to a third of their income on childcare – much higher than in other developed countries – anything to help with the costs is of course very welcome.

But the benefits of nanny share aren’t just about costs. Children learn to share, take turns, and resolve conflict by having another child around, just as they would in a natural family grouping. Parents often find that they become good friends with their nanny share family. It also means that when the phone rings with the disastrous news that the nanny is sick, there are four people who might possibly be able to take a ‘working from home’ day rather than just two!

As we now have over 500 families in our nanny share network, we’ve learned a lot about how to make a nanny share work. Here are our top tips.

  • Local is best. While shares a couple of tube stops away can work well, most of our shares are within a short walking distance. This is easiest for coordinating between two houses—and manoeuvring a double buggy.
  • The nanny has to be enthusiastic about it. Most nannies love the idea of adding in an extra child in exchange for a higher hourly rate. But not all of them do! Have a frank word. While you’re at it, ask your nanny what her ‘nanny share rate’ would be. It’s usually about £2 per hour higher than her sole rate.
  • After school nanny shares can work well. If you’ve had a nanny for a while and now only need her after school – which means you’re paying for lots of daytime hours you don’t need – another family can employ her during the day with a share after school. You’ll still need to make a contribution during the day, as that’s the price you pay for keeping your options open (otherwise the other family would just get their own nanny). But you will save a bundle, and you’ll keep your nanny involved in your child’s life.
  • Don’t restrict your preferences to same-aged children.  Although first-time sharers often request that the other family have the same aged child as theirs, in fact we’ve seen lots of highly successful shares with different ages, such as a baby and a toddler. Each can learn a lot from being around the other, and a good nanny will have no problem looking after them both at once.
  • Stick with your payroll provider.  Nanny shares can be notoriously complicated from a tax perspective, but your payroll provider has seen it all before and will be invaluable in helping you navigate through it.

At Koru Kids we help match families for nanny share. Families that already have a nanny in place tell us where they live, and we present them with a curated list of options from within our database of families seeking nanny shares.  If you already employ a nanny, the service is completely free to you and there’s no obligation to proceed with any match.

 

What our customers say

A highly professional, responsive, organised and good value service. Thank you.

Liza Knight

Thank you very much for your wonderful nanny payroll service. I don’t think I could of handled it all without you!

Elliot – London

Paymynanny.net takes away all the admin headaches of employing a nanny. I just tell them the rate of pay and the number of hours she works and they do the rest: the calculations, the payslips and the tax returns. The service is cheery, knowledgeable, responsive and accurate and worth every penny.

Catherine Mitchell

Friendly and professional service. Pay My Nanny were always very quick to respond to any queries and extremely reliable. They made employing a nanny much less stressful. We wouldn’t hesitate to recommend or use again.

Melanie Mcilvar

Thanks for all your hard work in running our nanny payrolls so brilliantly. We are no longer going to be employing nannies – the kids are at school at last!

Emily Corbishley

Paymynanny provides an excellent, convenient, reliable and affordable service. They’re always available to answer any questions and they take all the hassle and complications away from employing a nanny.

Dominic Gresset

I am very satisfied with the professional services of ‘paymynanny’ and would highly recommend them to other families. Knowing the nanny tax paperwork is being completed on my behalf has ensured my mum-to-do-list has one less thing on it.

Emma – London
© 2025 Pay My Nanny - All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Website created by: stellasoft